Rapid Response - Budget increases tax complexity and is likely to weigh on private investment

The Budget’s core tax changes tighten concessions for housing and capital gains, introduce new minimum tax rates on certain investment income, and offer only targeted relief for businesses and start‑ups. Taken together, they both introduce more complexity into tax planning and raise the effective tax burden, while slowing private sector investment.

• Key tax measures proposed in the Budget papers for individuals:

  • Limiting negative gearing on residential property to new builds from July 2027 (Treasury language: “from July next year”). Existing geared positions and established dwellings held before the start date remain under current rules.

  • Replacing the 50% capital gains tax (CGT) discount for individuals and trusts with an inflation‑indexed CGT regime.

  • Introducing a minimum 30% tax rate on capital gains for individuals from July 2027, and a minimum 30% tax rate on distributions from discretionary trusts from July 2028, aiming to better align taxation of investment income with tax on wages.

  • Preserving the 50% CGT discount for new residential builds acquired after Budget night.

  • Implementing a package of personal income tax cuts, including a new ongoing $250 “Working Australians Tax Offset” from the second half of 2027, positioned as the largest single cost‑of‑living measure.Making a $1,000 instant work‑related deduction for individuals (flagged in pre‑Budget commentary and referenced in the “simpler for workers” language).

• For Businesses:

  • Permanent two‑year loss carry‑back for companies up to $1 billion turnover, reducing income volatility.

  • Loss refundability for start‑ups in their first two years to support early‑stage investment.

  • Expanded venture capital tax incentives and more targeted R&D Tax Incentive support.

  • A permanent instant $20k per asset asset write‑off and more dynamic PAYG instalments for small business.

  • For high‑growth start‑ups with outsized nominal gains, the switch to real‑gain taxation partially offsets the removal of the discount, but the 30 % floor still increases tax relative to founders currently realising gains in middle marginal brackets with the 50% discount applied.

  • Founders using discretionary trusts for shareholdings face an explicit 30% minimum tax on trust distributions from July 2028, curtailing the ability to stream gains to low‑income beneficiaries or retain income tax‑effectively.

  • Net effect: operating‑stage tax settings are more favourable (loss relief, incentives, simpler write‑offs), but life‑cycle after‑tax returns for successful founders tilt down, especially where they previously relied on the 50% CGT discount and trust streaming.

• Housing investors and negative gearing:

  • Limiting negative gearing to new residential builds from July 2027 restricts the tax benefit of highly leveraged investment in established property.

  • Existing geared portfolios are grandfathered, but future acquisitions of established dwellings will no longer allow rental losses to offset other income, reducing the appeal of leveraged property accumulation as a tax shelter.

  • New builds remain favoured both through continued negative gearing and retention of the 50 % CGT discount, explicitly to channel capital into additional supply rather than bidding up existing stock.

• Capital gains tax across asset classes

  • For individuals and trusts, the end of the 50% CGT discount and move to inflation‑indexed gains plus a 30% minimum CGT rate increases the effective tax rate on long‑held, low‑yield assets (property, equities, business interests) that previously benefited from the 50% discount.

  • For foreign investors, these measures sit alongside already‑announced CGT expansions to a wider range of “Australian real property” assets (including infrastructure and associated rights), further broadening the taxable base.

• Portfolio investors:

  • Long‑term holders of listed equities outside super will see higher expected tax on gains, particularly those realising gains while in higher marginal brackets, though again real‑gain indexation matters for asset classes where price growth tracks inflation.

  • The broader message is a nudge from tax‑favoured capital gains toward ordinary income (wages, dividends, super contributions), which may shift portfolio design for some investors.

• NDIS

  • The Government will “secure the future of the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) by returning it to its original intent of providing reasonable and necessary supports for Australians with permanent and significant disability.”

  • This is framed as a structural saving: part of the $63.8 billion in savings and reprioritisations in this update, and the $177.9 billion in savings since the 2022 PEFO.

• Investment packages announced:

  • Fuel security and resilience: A $14.8 billion “Strengthening Australia’s Fuel Resilience” package, including a $7.5 billion Fuel and Fertiliser Security Facility and a $3.2 billion Australian Fuel Security Reserve.

  • Health and hospitals: An “additional” $25 billion investment for public hospitals (over the forward estimates).

  • Defence: A record additional $53 billion in defence funding.

  • Transport infrastructure: $8.6 billion for nationally significant road and rail projects.

  • Science, research and innovation (selected items): $387.4 million for CSIRO. $273.0 million for the National Measurement Institute. $21.7 million for the Australian Space Agency, plus continued funding for the Square Kilometre Array.

  • More than $39.1 billion committed to support R&D across higher education, grants, scientific organisations, defence capability and agriculture over the forward estimates.

• Updated macro forecasts:

  • Treasury emphasises that growth in 2026‑27 is revised down relative to earlier expectations because the Middle East conflict and associated oil shock weigh on real incomes and consumption, with recovery to 2.25% in 2027‑28 contingent on oil prices easing from mid‑2026.

  • The Budget explicitly states that headline inflation is now forecast at 5% through the year to June quarter 2026, up from earlier forecasts, and to decline back to 2.5% by June quarter 2027 as oil prices fall and temporary pressures unwind; excluding fuel, inflation is expected to be sustainably within the RBA band by mid‑2027.

  • Treasury describes the labour market as remaining “resilient”, with unemployment rising only gradually from 4.25% to 4.5% despite the weaker near‑term growth profile.

  • Over 2025‑26 to 2029‑30, cumulative underlying cash deficits sum to $150.5b, with the Budget position described as $44.9b stronger over the forward estimates than at MYEFO, largely from higher receipts and savings. The net policy decisions are expected improve the budget by $26.1b over the forward estimates.

  • Gross debt is forecast to peak within the forward estimates at 35.8% of GDP and then decline to 27.2% of GDP by 2036‑37.

  • The Budget projects a return to balance in 2034‑35 and a surplus of 0.8% of GDP by 2036‑37, driven by structural savings and the tax‑reform package.

• S&P/ASX200 8,638 -0.4%, AUDUSD 0.7237 -0.04%, Aus 2yr 4.77% +4bps, Aus 10yr 5.07% +4bp

Fin-X Wealth View

• The Treasurer explicitly framed the reforms as rebalancing a system where house prices have “decoupled from incomes” and is using reductions in investor concessions to fund tax cuts for workers. If legislated, these changes raise the long‑run tax take from passive and leveraged wealth while preserving targeted concessions where they align with policy priorities (new housing supply, high‑impact innovation).

• Higher effective CGT and constrained negative gearing are designed to reduce future demand for established property as an investment class and modestly reweight capital toward business investment, infrastructure, and genuine new housing, which continue to benefit from offsetting interest costs.

• However, many of the provisions will be grandfathered, undermining the aims with respect to existing asset owners. Investors will be encouraged to hold on to older housing for longer, while significant changes to incentives and increased complexity might outweigh many of the benefits outside housing.

• The coexistence of grandfathered assets, carve‑outs for new builds, minimum tax rates and indexation will raise planning complexity for high‑wealth individuals and founders in particular.

• The combination of higher effective CGT on exits and a higher floor on trust income likely pushes entrepreneurs toward company‑centred structures, with more attention to franked dividends versus capital gains as the extraction mechanism. The danger is more incentive to distribute rather than reinvest earnings over the long term.

• The projections ignore any possibility that higher taxes could be pushed onto customers, increasing some inflationary pressures. Moreover, the forecasts indicate a slowdown in private investment, which seems to run counter to the RBA’s complaint that domestic demand is outstripping domestic supply. Investment in supply is needed to support the growing population.

• Outside of the instant asset write-offs and new builds, it’s difficult to understand why the Treasury would want to penalise investment at a time of significant technological change that could benefit large parts of the service economy, not just VC-backed potential unicorns. Higher taxes on consumption (GST) would arguably have contributed to a more favourable balance.

• The Treasury’s forecasts appear optimistic. Inflation could well return to target by the end of the next financial year, but likely with a more substantial rise in unemployment if demand slows as a result of tighter fiscal and monetary policy.

• Overall, with so many different measures that are constraining and stimulative at the same time, it's difficult to gauge the net impact even before the legislation is passed. In addition, the risks of unintended consequences appear high.

Disclaimer

The contents of this communication is prepared by Brerona Capital Asset Management Pty Ltd (A.C.N. 627 650 293; AFSL 520526). The information contained in this communication is general in nature and does not take into consideration any investors personal objectives, goals, needs and financial situation. You should not rely on the information contained in this document to make any investment decisions without first consulting an investment professional such as your financial adviser. Any unauthorised use of this document is prohibited. This document (including any attachments) is intended only for the addressee, it may contain information of a privileged and confidential nature. If you are not the addressee of this communication, you must not copy, reproduce, disseminate or use this email and its contents. If this communication has been received in error by you, please inform us immediately and securely delete. Sharing, transmitting, copying, disseminating all or part of the contents of this document may result in a breach of the Federal Privacy Legislation and or copyright and trademark infringement of Brerona Capital Asset Management Pty Ltd and its related entities.